Selective Constraint on Ultraconserved Elements

Blogging on Peer-Reviewed Research

There's been a lot of recent interest in sequences that are highly conserved between humans and other mammals (and even other non-mammalian vertebrates). These sequences are thought to be under purifying selection, which prevents the accumulation of substitutions after two evolutionary lineages diverge. We cannot rule out, however, that the sequences are conserved by either pure chance (ie, in a large enough dataset, there will be a substantial amount of outliers that are still part of the same distribution) or because they have a lower mutation rate.

David Haussler is one of the leaders in the study of ultraconserved sequences in the human genome. In an attempt to understand the evolutionary dynamics of the ultraconserved sequences, Haussler and colleagues studied the patterns of polymorphism in these regions. Population genetics theory predicts that, if natural selection were responsible for the conservation of these sequences, they should also have low levels of polymorphism because natural selection would be purging newly arising mutations before they reach appreciable frequencies.

Haussler and colleagues found that there is a marked excess of rare alleles segregating in human populations at these ultraconserved elements. New mutations in ultraconserved elements stick around long enough to be found in a couple of individuals, but they are removed from the populations. In fact, this excess of rare alleles is even greater than that in protein coding regions, indicating that the ultraconserved elements are under more purifying selection than regular genes.


Katzman S, Kern AD, Bejerano G, Fewell G, Fulton L, Wilson RK, Salama SR, and Haussler D. 2007. Human genome ultraconserved elements are ultraselected. Science. 317: 915. doi:10.1126/science.1142430

More like this

Put a fork in 'em. The ultraconservative in centrist's clothing is toast.
The broadcast networks that air the Super Bowl have historically rejected advocacy ads. Yet CBS, which is airing the Super Bowl this year, has accepted an anti-choice ad by the ultra-conservative group Focus on the Family.
Okay, this is just hilarious. A reader left a link to this and I had to move it up here. It's John Lofton on the Daily Show, being interviewed by Stephen Colbert about a children's book written by Lynne Cheney.
A woman should not show BOTH of her eyes through her veil. This may encourage her to use eye make up. Two made up eyes peering out of the black veil is just too much to take.