Is Science Outreach Good if the Facts are Wrong?

i-6e06a1981d5ef17d00892c7fd4346f76-Floyd2_sm.jpg

The Canadian research organization Genome BC has unveiled a science education website, Genomics Education. One of the features of the website is Floyd the Fruit Fly, who, we can only presume, is some sort of cartoon drosophilid. Or maybe he's a tephritid, but I highly doubt it. When you hear "fruit fly" and "genetics", you think Drosophila, even if they really aren't fruit flies.

In the accompanying illustration, we see Floyd with smelly feet. Apparently, Floyd thinks that his foot stank is due to mitosis. He then learns, via a disembodied voice backed up by a soundtrack from an early Ron Jeremy film, that mitosis is cell division. The first half of the video, however, is spent going into way too much detail regarding DNA replication, transcription, and translation. The whole thing is an example of information overload and failing to direct the focus on the material that is allegedly being covered.

And then there's Floyd. Take a look at him. He's got two four legs (or two legs and two arms). And they're growing out of what appears to be the space between his gray abdomen and gigantic head. And that head! It's like an orange on a toothpick. But where the hell is Floyd's thorax? And his fifth and sixth legs? Has he got a mutation in a homeobox gene? Flies are insects, and insects are hexapods, and hexapods, as the name suggests, have six legs. And a thorax where those legs (and the wings) are attached. It's one thing to take a few liberties in illustrating a cartoon animal; it's another to totally butcher the anatomy.

The Genomics Education website seems like a good idea. As of now, it's in its infancy, so it's impossible to provide a thorough evaluation. But there is some promise that it could become a valuable resource for students and science educators, provided they don't get sloppy and play fast and loose with the facts.

More like this

I'm a huge Pink Floyd fan.
For many years, and in particular during my college years, I was a huge Pink Floyd fan. Indeed, I suspect the first trace of me on the internet probably involves a post on a Pink Floyd newsgroup of which I am now quite embarrassed (but my ideas was sound, damnit!).
The keyboardist for Pink Floyd passed away today. He was 65, and had been through a long battle with cancer. He wrote several of the band's famous songs, including Great Gig In The Sky and Us And Them, both from Dark Side Of The Moon.
Over at the fact builders blog, the fact master discusses The Physics of....Pink Floyd.

4 legs - it's a biblical insect.

By Mustafa Mond, FCD (not verified) on 14 May 2007 #permalink