FOXNews Producer Caught Rallying Tea-Bagger Protest

Fair and balanced ain't what it used to. The Huffington Post has published video of FOXNews producer Heidi Noonan encouraging protesters at the 9/12 event to be loud and boisterous while Griff Jenkins "reported" on their outrage. Noonan is seen motioning to the crowd periodically while speaking to an unknown individual on her cell phone. At one point she attempts to hide from the camera that has her in the shot.

Here is the video released at HuffPo:

Now here is the "objective" reporting that viewers at home saw (via Media Matters):

Notice how Jenkins and Beck both claim that this movement is a grassroots campaign and reject the accusation of "astroturfing" (promoting the illusion of outrage through an effective media campaign). I know it's a rather tired point at this stage of the game, but does Fox have any notion of what hypocrisy means?

More like this

Politicians and activists know that one of the most effective ways to discredit critics is to try to portray them as (1) being in the pay of someone else, such as a big corporation, or (2) part of an "organized" effort to criticize them, or (3) preferably both. That's why antivaccine cranks are so…
Whatever you think of its political reporting, no other mainstream media outlet can bring the stupid like the Huffington Post, especially with regards to medical reporting. Its most famous contributors include antivaccinationists like David Kirby and Robert Kennedy, Jr., and kumbaya therapy…
You have no idea how long I have been sitting on this one. I made some videos like a billion years ago, and still no post. Why? Oh well, here it is. I like video analysis of motion. I like looking at stuff on youtube or other video sites. But sometimes, you need to make the video yourself.…
Funny how everything old is new again, isn't it? Yes, if there's one thing I've learned over nearly six years of blogging, it's that, sooner or later, everything is recycled, and I do mean everything. At least, that was the thought going through my mind when I came across PZ's discussion of a…

...does Fox have any notion of what hypocrisy means?

But you see, hypocrisy by it's nature cannot possibly apply to them, or their political comrades-in-arms.

does Fox have any notion of what hypocrisy means?

Don't know if they're aware of the meaning, but I'm quite sure they don't care.

By Physicalist (not verified) on 23 Sep 2009 #permalink

lefty naivette

of course there will always be amn element of instigation in any movement, protestors dont just show up at a particular time and place spontaneously.

The question is one of degree.

I will argue that the left media ( the majority BTW) just by its sheer dominace in numbers is exponentially guiltier of this so called astroturfing. phenomenon.

VIC: Left Media? In he United States? I would dearly like to see that, but expect to live so long.