Guest Post: Prof. Eilam Gross

eilam gross annual 2010 head 333.jpgThe Weizmann Institute's Prof. Eilam Gross is currently the ATLAS Higgs physics group convener. He originally wrote this piece in Hebrew for the Yediot Aharonot daily.

The Best There Is - For Now

"The God Particle," as the Higgs boson is often called, comes from the title of the book by Nobel laureate Leon Lederman that deals with the search for the elusive particle. This particle, according to the Standard Model of Particle Physics, is responsible for giving mass to all of the elementary particles in nature.

The mass of an electron determines the size of a hydrogen atom; ultimately the size of atoms ensures, amazingly enough, our existence. Maybe this is the reason the Higgs has been treated with almost mystical reverence in the mass media.

The Higgs boson is the only one of the elementary particles making up the Standard Model of Particle Physics that has not yet been discovered. Its importance can't be denied. Many scientists believe that the Standard Model will stand or fall on the discovery of Higgs boson particles or proof that they don't exist.

Three weeks ago, I attended a conference called "Higgs hunting" in Paris. Nearly everyone who is involved in the search for this particle was there. I was the guest of my friend Marumi Kado. At some point after a wonderful, wine-filled dinner, Marumi suggested a glass of grappa. "You must," he said. "It is Prime Uve, the best there is." A few hours later, in the wee hours of the morning, Marumi nudged me awake from a deep sleep and said: "Eilam, do you want to see a Higgs?" Of course, I jumped up immediately: "What? Where?" "The computer has stopped running; here are the results," he said. On his computer screen were images from CERN. We were all in shock. Something was out of the ordinary at a mass of 126 GeV (a unit of mass close to that of a proton). Definitely significant - 3.6 standard deviations. We couldn't believe our eyes - we looked at the screen for ages before we started to digest what we were seeing. For the past three weeks, the entire Higgs search team in the ATLAS experiment have checked and rechecked the results from every possible angle. We checked for errors... for bugs in the program.


In 2011 the LHC particle accelerator in Geneva collided over 300 trillion (a million million) protons in two opposing beams. All of that enormous energy (7 trillion electron volts) went into the effort to produce the Higgs boson. In each collision, other similar particles are created and there is no way to foresee what will be found. Quantum field theory enables us to predict the chances of a certain particle being created. The calculations show that the likelihood of getting a Higgs out of a particular collision is so small that over the course of a year we can't see the signs of more than a hundred or so (with a mass of 126 GeV).


In figure 2 we see the result of a collision that looks like a Higgs. But is this a Higgs particle? The problem is that we don't know enough to conclusively identify it. It could look like hundreds or thousands of other particles produced in the collisions. How can we tell?

We don't know for sure! What we can do is count how many of the collision outcomes look similar to a Higgs, and we can calculate how many of these we expect to see in the Standard Model without the Higgs. On the basis of observation, we can compute the probability that the number of collisions that result in particles similar to a Higgs boson will fit the Standard Model (without the Higgs). The numerical value of that probability is called p0.

If there is no Higgs, we would expect that value to be around 0.5 (50%), i.e., the same as the chance that the flip of a coin will come up heads.

But if the Higgs exists, we should get "extra" collision results with a mass in the range that the Higgs might have. Of course, even if there is no Higgs, there could be statistical fluctuations affecting the experimental results. But the chances of such fluctuations are low (that is, they have a small p0).

In figure 1 we see the results of the measurement of the ATLAS detectors in CERN (as they were presented today by CERN spokeswoman Fabiola Giannoti).

In most of the masses (between 110 and 150 GeV) the p0 value is around 0.5, as expected if there were no Higgs. But right around 126 GeV, the p0 probability drops to 0.00019, that is, there is a chance of about 1 in 5000 that the "extra" events observed at this specific mass are the result of a statistical fluke rather than the creation of a Higgs boson.

Moreover, had we seen such a peak at a different mass it would also been considered as a possible Higgs signal. This increases the chances that the observed "extra" events are the result of a statistical fluke. (This is called the "Look Elsewhere Effect").

Does all of this prove the existence of the Higgs boson? Everyone must judge for him or herself the significance of those two hundredths of a percent.

My opinion is - maybe. Maybe yes. Maybe no. It depends.

First, we must see what the results are from the competition - CMS. Unfortunately, CMS did not measure the statistical fluctuations. They measured two statistical anomalies that may be evidence for the Higgs: one with a mass of 119 GeV and another with a mass of 124 GeV, both with a significance of 1%. That is, the chance of getting the CMS results without the Higgs is not that low (1 in 100).

But it is likely that if we combine the two results, we might perhaps see the first signs of a Higgs in one of two possible places: 119 GeV and around 125 GeV (the average of 124 AND 126) with a relatively high level of confidence.

Will we ever conclusively find the Higgs?

It seems that the year 2012 will reveal it to us. In April 2012, the collider will start up again, apparently at a higher energy and greater collision frequency.

We can expect that the summer of 2012 will be a summer of tidings.

More like this

"There are no physicists in the hottest parts of hell, because the existence of a 'hottest part' implies a temperature difference, and any marginally competent physicist would immediately use this to run a heat engine and make some other part of hell comfortably cool." -Richard Davisson The Large…
"Give me a coin. <Takes Coin.> All right. Uh... heads, I win, tails, you lose. Right? <Flips coin.> Tails, you lose." -Ralph Kramden All things being equal, you're well aware that if you flipped a completely fair coin, you'd have a 50% chance of it landing on heads, and a 50% chance of…
The Higgs Boson, an elementary particle thought to give mass to all other particles, remains an elusive final piece of the Standard Model of physics. On The Weizmann Wave, Professor Eilam Gross writes "many scientists believe that the Standard Model will stand or fall on the discovery of Higgs…
From CERN: CERN experiments observe particle consistent with long-sought Higgs boson Geneva, 4 July 2012. At a seminar held at CERN1 today as a curtain raiser to the year’s major particle physics conference, ICHEP2012 in Melbourne, the ATLAS and CMS experiments presented their latest preliminary…

This is very interesting! In April when the collider starts up again, will it also be colliding 300 trillion protons again? Or will it be using more/less? Also, when can we expect to see the results? I am thrilled and can't wait to find out!

By TheZooKeeper (not verified) on 15 Dec 2011 #permalink

Ãzel bir donanım ve ekipman gerektiren; fuar taÅımacılıÄı, çelik ve zırhlı kasa taÅımacılıÄı ve daha riskli olan piyano taÅıma hizmetlerini de büyük bir baÅarı ile ve sorunsuz olarak gerçekleÅtiren Sarıyer Evden,e Eve Nakliyat Firması, sadece araçları ile deÄil, taÅınmanın aÅamaları olan; eÅya demonte, paketleme, kolileme ve hamaliye iÅlerini de elemanları vasıtası ile sizlerin yerine yapmaktadır.