Jenny McCarthy not dumb enough for ya?

Yes, that's right, the Huffington Post, that broadsheet of blarney, that tabloid of medical trumpery has done it. Not content to risk our mental health by lending legitimacy to all kinds of pseudoscientific charlatans, they just let Jim Carrey write a piece on vaccines and autism. Yes, the boyfriend of uber-fukwit Jenny McCarthy has drunk her Kool Aid, but that's no surprise. I'll leave a good fisking to others, because a few of the commenters showed signs of higher cortical function, and this deserves some coverage.

Take this one for example

I think Jim and Jenny McCarthy are instilling more guilt and fear in parents and the end result is the children do not get the inteventions they need to help them. If the energy was placed in offering and providing autistic children proven therapies that help them participate in a full life (i.e. ABA) then all our kids would benefit. Instead a very vocal celebrity is focusing the attention on psuedo/junk science and her child who may have actually been misdiagnosed. Just one more thing for anxious parents to feel guilty about? Very irresponsible and I spend much of my time reassuring parents that they are doing the very best they can and to NOT read anything Jenny publishes or rants about on Larry King. Jenny is selling books and making non-proven theories very profitable for her quasi-doctor friends on the backs of autistic kids and their parents.

I'd like to expand on an important point made by this commenter, who is a parent of an autistic child. There is a punitive tone to much of so-called alternative medicine. I agree with the commenter that this idiocy helps engender a useless sense of guilt in parents. It makes them feel they have to choose between protecting their kids from infectious diseases and protecting them from autism. If they've already vaccinated their kids, then it makes them feel they've harmed their children.

This punitive approach takes a couple of forms. Take these comments from earlier threads:

Yes, presciptions are easier and cheaper to prescribe. But often, they are an attempt to undo the damage that the patient constantly inflicts upon themselves.

In this case, the commenter expresses a common sentiment, that the patient has caused their illness. This may be true, but what is the corollary? Let's ask a naturopathic doctor. With regards to a diabetic patient:

I send him home with "Dr. Richard Bernstein's Diabetes Solution" ...He has to read at least the chapters on the diet. He does a diet diary for a week and records his fasting, and 1.5 hr post-prandial glucose levels as well. ... I'm not too concerned with his 230 blood sugar; with my protocol that will come down substantially ...I'll send him away with blood work orders at local lab, diet diary, chart to record his blood sugars, prescriptions if necessary, Bernstein's book, a clearly detailed Treatment sheet.

He'll come back next week when I'll go over the blood work with him, describe the strict Low Carb diet he must follow via a very detailed handout I have, which includes components of eating healthily as well. I also go over the supplements I'll put him on (vitamins, minerals, fish oils, herbs, accessory nutrients), recommend exercise (if he has been cleared by the cardiologist), stress relaxation techniques which resonate with him, if necessary. Let's say he's NOT on insulin, so I don't have to describe all the comprehensive ways I deal with that. I give him directions that if his blood sugars go down frequently below 100 mg/dl to call me ... I will see him weekly or every two weeks until he is stable and we have dealt with all problems, which usually just takes 2-3 visits. We will lower or remove medicines, as necessary...

So, if the patient's behavior is a major factor in their illness, what happens when they don't change their behavior? What if the patient can't do all that she recommends? What if the patient tries to follow her guru's diet book but fails? What if he doesn't even try? What if he starts smoking? Will she view that as her failure? As his?

The first day of my Pathology class, my professor asked, "Why do people come to the doctor?" People gave lots of answers, but he held up his hand and said, "Because they hurt," and he meant this in a very inclusive way---physical pain, worry, loneliness---all of these things drive people to the doctor. Few visits to my office fall under the "just checking in" category.

Patients come to see us to feel better. They often care little about how they get there. In medicine, there are many ways to become ill, many of which involve poor health practices on the part of the patient. These poor health practices often continue no matter how well you educate and support them. How should we treat our patients when they fail to heed our advice? Should we berate them? Should we tell them we have nothing else to offer?

Yes, we should try our best to help our patients change, but when we tell them that we have only one best way to help them, and then they fail, we've lost them. This is about real people, real lives, real suffering, and it frustrates me to no end that others are blind to this.

More like this

Yesterday I issued a challenge to naturopathic physicians to justify why they should be considered competent primary care physicians. The best and most comprehensive answer received so far is the one from "Mona". Here is my analysis. Her response, while not entirely "wrong", shows a frightening…
I know, I know. Picking on Jenny McCarthy over her now frequent idiotic statements about autism and her parroting of the myth that vaccines cause autism is like shooting fish in a barrel, boxing a one-armed opponent, playing tennis with a blind man (like the infamous Saturday Night Live sketch from…
Yesterday, I wrote a post about what fellow ScienceBlogger Isis would term "hot, hot science." As much as I love science like that, writing such posts is a lot of work and takes considerably longer than my run-of-the-mill bit of insolent brilliance. Often, after writing an analysis of a peer-…
I don't watch Private Practice. I didn't like Grey's Anatomy, which, every time I caught part of it, struck me as the cheesiest sort of medical soap opera, a General Hospital transplanted to prime time. Given that Private Practice is a spinoff of Grey's Anatomy, I never saw any reason whatsoever to…

I'm an autistic adult . . . I didn't have any help at all, I was much more 'symptomatic" as a kid but I've learned to compensate, and I still turned out all right. I wish sometimes I could talk to parents who are being confused and scared out of their wits by the hype, misinformation and woo.

By Omphaloskepsis (not verified) on 22 Apr 2009 #permalink

Ha! I saw this on HuffPost earlier, and was thinking, "Oh, I'll need to check PalMD and Orac later..."

It's nice to see that some of the commenters are pushing back against the Jim and Jenny fear/guilt-mongering.


thank you for your post. my 15 yr old stepson is PDD NOS. his symptoms are much better now than they were 7 yrs ago. he still displays the symptoms he did when he was younger, but getting older seems to be helping him cope with it better. if you met him for the first time you probably wouldn't notice, unless you have experience with the autism spectrum. i like to think that he will be able to turn out all right too.

Standing ovation to that commenter! I am so glad that comment actually made it through their no-free-speech-here moderation!

Also, standing ovation to this:
"Yes, we should try our best to help our patients change, but when we tell them that we have only one best way to help them, and then they fail, we've lost them. This is about real people, real lives, real suffering, and it frustrates me to no end that others are blind to this."

Pal, you are speaking sense to insanity, and I applaud you for it! This is truly what I don't like about "alt med"; no matter what you do, how healthy you are, eventually everyone gets sick, and everyone will die. The blame is so caustic, it makes me weep. Sometimes bad things happen and it's no one's fault. Let's make things better, then go around placing blame.

By JustaTech (not verified) on 23 Apr 2009 #permalink