Humaniqueness and the PFC

A nice summary of "humaniquness," or the cognitive talents that make homo sapiens such an unprecedented species:

[Marc] Hauser describes animals as having "laser-beam" intelligence, in which each cognitive capacity is locked into a specific function. Humans, by contrast, have "floodlight" intelligence, he says: they can use a single system of thought in multiple ways and can translate information from one context to another. "Animals," he elaborates, "live in a world in which the systems don't talk to each other."

This sort of abstract cognition is generally thought to reside in the prefrontal cortex (PFC), the fold of brain stuffed behind the forehead. (The same nub of tissue also plays a crucial role in self-control, which is why stuff like this can happen.) While the PFC is now celebrated as the Promethean part of the cortex, responsible for rationality, logic and all those executive functions, it wasn't always held in such high regard. In 1935, the Portuguese neurologist Antonio Egas Moniz performed the first prefrontal leucotomy, a delicate surgery in which small holes were cut into the frontal lobes. (The surgery was inspired by reports of chimpanzees becoming less aggressive after undergoing similar procedures.) Moniz restricted the surgery to patients with severe psychiatric problems, such as schizophrenia, who would otherwise be confined to dismal mental institutions. The leucotomy certainly wasn't a cure-all, but many of Moniz's patients did experience a dramatic reduction in symptoms. In 1949, he was awarded the Nobel Prize in Medicine for pioneering the procedure.

The success of the leucotomy led doctors to experiment with other kinds of frontal lobe operations. In the United States, Walter Freeman and James Watts developed a procedure known as the transorbital lobotomy, which was designed to completely ablate the tracts of white matter connecting the prefrontal cortex and the thalamus. The surgery was brutally simple: a thin blade was inserted just under the eyelid, hammered through a thin a layer of bone, and shimmied from side to side. The treatment quickly became exceedingly popular. Between 1939 and 1951, the "cutting cure" was performed on more than 18,000 patients in American asylums and prisons.

Unfortunately, the surgery came with a wide range of tragic side-effects. Between 2 and 6 percent of all patients died on the operating table. Those who survived were never the same. Some patients sank into a stupor, utterly uninterested in everything around them. Others lost the ability to use language. (This is what happened to Rosemary Kennedy, the sister of President John F. Kennedy. Her lobotomy was given as treatment for "agitated depression.") The vast majority of lobotomized patients suffered from short-term memory problems and the inability to control their impulses.

More like this

LOBOTOMY (from the Greek lobos, meaning lobes of the brain, and tomos, meaning cut) is a psychosurgical procedure in which the connections the prefrontal cortex and underlying structures are severed, or the frontal cortical tissue is destroyed, the theory being that this leads to the uncoupling…
My recent post on prefrontal lobotomy has been the most popular thing on this blog so far, and the comments on it are worth reading. While searching for more information about lobotomies and the neuroleptic drugs that replaced them, I came across this fantastic webpage at, which…
A forthcoming PBS documentary called The Lobotomist examines the career of psychiatrist Walter J. Freeman, who performed nearly 3,000 "ice pick" lobotomies during the late 1930s and 1940s. The hour-long program, which is partly based on Jack El-Hai's book of the same name, contains old footage of…
Here's some fascinating footage from 1942, showing Drs. James Watts and Walter Freeman performing a prefrontal leucotomy. The footage accompanies a short article called Lobotomy Revisited, and, like last week's trepanation film clip, is not for the squeamish.) The procedure shown in the film is the…

Jonah, thanks for this thoughtful post. I wanted to make one correction: The surgical procedure you describe is not prefrontal lobotomy, which Freeman and Watts performed more than 700 times between 1936 and 1946, but is instead transorbital lobotomy, an approach Freeman began using in 1946 and continued for 21 years. (Watts also performed a couple dozen transorbital lobotomies without Freeman.) The leucotome used in transorbital lobotomies had a pointed tip, not a blade.

Many thanks.

Jack El-Hai
Author, The Lobotomist: A Maverick Medical Genius and His Tragic Quest to Rid the World of Mental Illness (Wiley, 2005; paperback 2007)

Hauser's piece is contemplative. The PFC friendly crowd that hangs out here is good at absorbing and remixing information to use in varied situations, so we must be human. We may not have the power of flight, but can vividly imagine flying. Do birds imagine blogging?
The PFC surgical interventions, along with current chemical treatments, seem to have the goal of transforming one unique individual into a more socially acceptable norm, or member of the herd. Restoration of self without its destruction is a goal that appears to be uniquely human, but we're just beginners.

Thanks so much for the correction! (I really loved your book, by the way.) I've since amended the post.

There was a blue-jean covered leucotome in the blue-jean cabinet I exhibited in New York. I am glad I was born after
those experiments. I think we will find that we have a great deal of power ready for us to harness ourselves in our minds, just waiting there to assist our healing. Thanks.

By lee pirozzi (not verified) on 20 Nov 2008 #permalink