Ian Musgrave on Jury-Rigged Design

If you have not checked out the Panda's Thumb, I recommend starting with this post by Ian Musgrave. It is a devestating critique of an article by Discovery Institute fellow Jonathan Witt. Ian is an Australian biochemist and he simply shreds Witt's arguments against the argument from jury-rigged design. It is an appropriate venue for such an article, since the "panda's thumb" is a textbook example of how evolution cobbles together useful structures out of existing ones, as would be expected. If an omnipotent designer had started from scratch, it would certainly have done a better job of it because, unlike evolution, such a designer would not be constrained. The human eye is another great example of jury-rigged design. At any rate, go read the entire article, as the work by Ian is excellent from beginning to end.

Tags

More like this

In addition to a bunch of work-related stuff, I'm trying to devote some time during my sabbatical to fixing various problems that have piled up around Chateau Steelypips over the last few years when I was too busy to deal with much of anything.
Damn, I must have ridden those very train carriages thousands of times! The crash happened just four stops up the commuter train line from where I live. My wife and I went there this morning with our camera.
World Science Festival Blog Of course they have a blog-- it's 2008, for God's sake...
Last year I went to a fascinating symposium in honor of the great evolutionary biologist George Williams.