SloppySecondsGate

(not an original moniker in the title, someone remind me where it came from so I can give credit where credit is due!)

While I think the approriate response to ClimateGate 2.0 is to ignore it, I also think the mainstream media is doing mostly just that so it is safer to bring your attention to this good rebuttal to the whole affair from potholer54 on YouTube:

I think the most telling quote echoing around the denialosphere right now is this one from Jonathan Overpeck:

The trick may be to decide on the main message and use that to guid what's included and what is left out.

It's supposed to reveal evil scientists twisting their research and data to support some preconceived message, "presumably global warming is scary, give us lots of grant money." But look what happens when you put in a tiny bit of context:

I think the hardest, yet most important part, is to boil the section down to 0.5 pages. In looking over your good outline, [...] you cover ALOT. The trick may be to decide on the main message and use that to guid what's included and what is left out.

Reality can be so boring....


(note the misspelling of "guide" that may frustrate text searches, like mine just now! So, for The Google: "The trick may be to decide on the main message and use that to guide what's included and what is left out". Now at least one relevant page will be returned!)

More like this

[Guest post by John Mashey] This is a second follow-up to the original falsification, flat-earth maps and dog astrology. Flat-earth is discussed here in More use and abuse of IPCC 1990 fig 7.1(c). This post explores the other topic: David Deming, "dog astrology journal" and then Jon Overpeck…
Potholer54 has written a letter to Monkton that you will want to read, and he's also made a video that you will want to see. First the letter (from here): Open letter to Christopher Monckton - please return to the debate Dear Mr. Monckton, A couple of months ago you entered into a debate with me…
So the readers have spoken: one more vote for hearing about my PI experience than the weird convo with the deans. However, I was working on the draft, and then some more work stuff got dumped on me, then SW had her popular deconstruction of one of Greg Laden's posts and I didn't want to interrupt…
tags: Birdbooker Report, bird books, animal books, natural history books, ecology books "How does one distinguish a truly civilized nation from an aggregation of barbarians? That is easy. A civilized country produces much good bird literature." --Edgar Kincaid The Birdbooker Report is a special…