Grilled meat and cancer?

i-6b9e84c840acac2bf014fae43a18e26a-grilled meat.jpg I was asked this question a while ago and found it quite interesting.

Can eating grilled meat cause cancer?

The idea that eating the charred part of grilled meat can increase your risk of certain cancers has been around for several years.

The science behind this is that when meat is exposed to high temperatures for long periods of time natural compounds in the meat form heterocyclic amines (HCAs) and polycyclicaromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) and these compounds have been linked to an increased risk of certain cancers in animal studies.

According to the American Institute for Cancer Research, however, the connection between these compounds and cancer in humans is not well delineated.

It has been suggested that people who eat A LOT of grilled meat (and "a lot" isn't really defined, unfortunately) might want to take some precautions but in my opinion there are other more important health issues to consider about meat such as its fat content and cholesterol amount.

FYI. If you ever want to ask a random science-related question feel free to submit it to the new and improved "Ask a ScienceBlogger" feature on the ScienceBlogs homepage where readers can submit questions to be answered by a ScienceBlogger expert in the field.

Technorati Tags: ,

Tags

More like this

By Ruthann Rudel and Dick Clapp Two recent papers by Ruthann Rudel and Julia Brody published in the journal Cancer compiled a list of 216 chemicals shown to cause mammary gland tumors in animal studies and presented a comprehensive state-of-the-science review of environmental factors in breast…
The safety of soda has been in the news a lot lately. The news even seems bad for diet coke, which hits close to home for me given my diet coke addiction. The worst seems to be this correlative study proposing a link between diet sodas and stroke risk: The study, which followed more than 2,500…
On Monday nights, it is time to see what is new in PLoS Medicine and PLoS Biology: Meat Consumption and Cancer Risk: Meat consumption in relation to cancer risk has been reported in over a hundred epidemiological studies from many countries with diverse diets. The association between meat intake…
Student guest post by Desiré Christensen Colorectal cancer (aka colon cancer) includes cancers of the colon, rectum, and appendix. Colorectal cancer is more common in developed countries (e.g. United States and Japan) compared to developing countries in Africa and Asia. Each year in the United…

I agree that individuals should first focus on the clear cancer causers, such as smoking, diet, radon exposure etc.

One study did show that avoiding grilled red meat that is very well done, burned or charred may help decrease the risk of developing pancreatic cancer (Cancer Epidemiology Biomarkers and Prevention). For those who enjoy grilled food, marninating meats for 40 minutes prior to grilling decreased the content of heterocyclic amines by 90 percent. Content of heterocyclic amines can also be lowered by microwaving meats for two minutes prior to grilling. Cut off any areas that are burned or charred prior to serving. Thanks!

Lynne Eldridge M.D.
Author, "Avoiding Cancer One Day At A Time, Practical Advice for Preventing Cancer"
http://www.avoidcancernow.com

I will always remember a BBQ apron Dave Letterman wore on the show: it said "Charbroiled meats contain known carcinogens!" He didn't wear it the day Martha Stewart was on, though.

Oh, and you'll definitely want to stay away from the smoked salmon. We analyzed some one time as part of a project on Alaskan subsistence foods (they were worried about levels after the Exxon Valdez spill)....the smoked salmon had by far the highest levels of anything we analyzed, especially of the more carcinogenic compounds (benzopyrene, etc.), which happen to be very low in crude oil...until it is combusted, anyway!

By Tlazolteotl (not verified) on 20 Apr 2007 #permalink