Channel 7 doesn't pluck the pigeons, they just lead them to slaughter

(This piece appears today at Science-Based Medicine and is re-posted here today because I like it and I'm lazy. --PalMD)

A couple of years ago, a number of us raised concerns about an "investigative reporter" at a Detroit television station.  At the time I noted that investigative reporters serve an important role in a democracy, but that they can also do great harm, as when Channel 7's Steve Wilson parroted the talking points of the anti-vaccine movement.  Wilson has since been canned but apparently, not much has changed.  While performing my evening ablutions, I stumbled upon the latest abomination.

The story is about a surgeon turned faith healer.  I can think of about a half-dozen different ways to make an interesting story out of this.  But Channel 7, rather than doing the harder but more interesting story about the chicanery of faith healers, presented an infomercial.

Dr. Issam Nemeh claims to be a surgeon and anesthesiologist.  I don't know how much he charges for that sort of work, but he charges twenty dollars a ticket for his faith healing services.  The deceptions used by faith healers have been well-documented elsewhere but one of their methods, like all altmed folks, is to claim to have cured a self-limited condition.  One of the conditions whose improvement the reporter credited to Nemeh was optic neuritis.  The report incorrectly calls optic neuritis a form of multiple sclerosis.  Optic neuritis is a common manifestation of MS, but it is also common in isolation.  In either case, it often improves spontaneously or with medication.  Like many alternative medicine gurus, Nemeh can take advantage of the natural history of a disease by taking credit for its natural remission.

And he is an altmed guru, not some conventional doc with a religious streak.  In addition to his faith-healing business, Issam runs a medical practice.  The news report calls him a "certified" surgeon, anesthesiologist, and acupuncturist.  I'm not sure what that means.  He is licensed to practice medicine by the state of Ohio.  He is not, however, certified by any board listed by the American Board of Medical Specialties.  But a medical license lets you treat  just about anything, and according to the first hit on google, that's just what he does, offering treatment to "all patients with any type of physical, mental or emotional disorder."  This includes children.  Dr. Nemeh offers two types of treatments: "meridian regulatory acupuncture" (tranlation:  "some impossible, lucrative needle thing that suckers will pay out of pocket for") and faith healing (translation: "some impossible, lucrative talky thing that suckers will pay out of pocket for").  He may be licensed to practice medicine, and Ohio may recognize acupuncture as something "medical", but in the educated opinion of this internist, what he does has nothing to do with the practice of medicine.

Nemeh is a shaman.  He uses the smoke and mirrors of some sort of acupuncture machine on any condition in any patient.  This is a hallmark of quackery---claiming that one modality can treat anything, when really, it's most efficient effect is to remove money from the pockets of its victims.  But Nemeh is pretty damned cleaver.   Some folks like modern-sounding shamanism, with its needles hooked up to bells, whistles, and pretty lights.  But others prefer that old time religion, and Nemeh's got that covered with his faith heeling business.

I have rarely seen such an efficient combination of modern and ancient healthcare thievery (in, of course, my humble opinion).   And despite the execrable nature of TV health reporting, I have never seen such a credulous infomercial presented as news.

Shame on you Dr. Nemeh, and shame on you Channel 7.

More like this

by Dick Clapp Atul Gawande is well-known around Boston because of his skills as a surgeon, but also for his books and articles in the New Yorker, and his interviews with local media.  He was a recipient of one of this yearâs MacArthur grants, in recognition of his work. I got one of his books, "…
Yesterday, I concluded that Dr. Mehmet Oz's journey to the Dark Side was continuing apace. After all, he had pulled the classic "bait and switch" of "alternative" medicine by allowing a man who calls himself Yogi Cameron to use his television show to co-opt the perfectly science-based modalities of…
Last night, I lambasted Countdown host Keith Olbermann for having been played by the antivaccine movement and having unjustly slimed British journalist Brian Deer. Clearly, Olbermann was so blinded by his hatred of Rupert Murdoch that all chief apologist for the antivaccine movement, former…
I didn't get to see this interview last night on Late Night With Conan O'Brien. After all, I usually show up at work between 7:00 and 7:30 AM. However, Hugh Laurie, star of House, was interviewed by Conan and revealed himself to be not unlike me in that he's definitely a booster of reason and…

"The story is about a surgeon turned faith healer."

When I first read that I seriously thought you were going to be talking about Dr. Mehmet Oz!

Oh, I love using the ABMS website and plan to keep up with my (quiet weekends) solicitation to them to make their website more accessible to visitors (no more signing up/logging in).

(Friendly aside: Your link to the ABMS website links to that of the previous.)

L.Ron Hubbard has him beat for combining pseudoscience nonsense and religion.

Here's an interesting observation from James Randi's book, "The Faith Healers" : (paraphrased) Many faith healers proudly display upon their wall rows of canes, crutches and walkers from people that they "healed". Not one glass eye, prosthetic limb or toupee up there.

By The Blind Watchmaker (not verified) on 20 Mar 2010 #permalink

I'm glad you felt lazy enough to reuse your piece because it me to stumble on to your topic. I appreciate the clarity of your position on these AltMeds.
I really wish more people would say something about all the incarnations of AltMed from the supernaturalists to the supplementalists.
The way they are allowed to practice without consequence to advertise the "as seen on TV" miracles in a jar products all need to be brought out into the light of day and exposed as the shams they are.

By Larry Waybright (not verified) on 23 Mar 2010 #permalink

"Ahhhhh, I see that you have the machine that goes...BING!"