The question is...


i-e31190af0099b59a5fc558c29c155597-twittereducation.jpg

Has anybody reading this post used twitter in the classroom? Not in the sense of:

"Students, write something witty in less than 140 characters"

But rather:

"Students, we don't mind you using twitter during class, but keep the tweets class specific. Oh yeah, and use this hashtag #subject101"

In other words, use the online tool in much the same way as a conference, but specifically for a class in, say, university.

I've had a chance to look at a number of articles here and there by searching "using twitter in classroom." This one, in particular, was interesting:

Professor Encourages Students to Pass Notes During Class -- via Twitter

Cole W. Camplese, director of education-technology services at Pennsylvania State University at University Park, prefers to teach in classrooms with two screens -- one to project his slides, and another to project a Twitter stream of notes from students. He knows he is inviting distraction -- after all, he's essentially asking students to pass notes during class. But he argues that the additional layer of communication will make for richer class discussions.

Mr. Camplese first tried out his idea in a course he co-taught last spring to about 20 graduate students at Penn State. He couldn't get two screens, so he had students bring in their laptops and follow the Twitter-powered peanut gallery on their machines during discussions.

Back then, most of his students were unfamiliar with Twitter, the microblogging service that limits messages to 140 characters. And for the first few weeks of course, students were reluctant to tweet, says Mr. Camplese. "It took a few weeks for this to click," he said. "Before it started to work, there was just nothing on the back channel."

Once students warmed to the idea that their professors actually wanted them to chat during class, students begin floating ideas or posting links to related materials, the professor says. In some cases, a shy student would type an observation or question on Twitter, and others in the class would respond with notes encouraging the student to raise the topic out loud. Other times, one of the professors would see a link posted by a student and stop class to discuss it.

Still, when Mr. Camplese told me about his experiment soon after he spoke at The Chronicle's Tech Forum, I couldn't help thinking that it sounded like a recipe for chaos, and I told him so. He replied that his hope is that the second layer of conversation will disrupt the old classroom model and allow new kinds of teaching in which students play a greater role and information is pulled in from outside the classroom walls. "I'm not a full-time faculty member," he said. "I use my classrooms as an applied-research lab to decide what to promote as new solutions for our campus."

He said he planned to try the technique again next time he teaches -- hopefully with the second screen installed. "My goal is to only teach in rooms that allow me to project from two different sources," he said. --Jeffrey R. Young

Still, I'm curious to hear general opinions on whether this is good thing to try out, or whether this is yet another thing that would distract or take away from the learning.

Anyway, any comments or leads would be great.

(p.s. totally took the above tweet idea from @sesamestreet, from Grover actually)

More like this

It seems to me that it would make more sense in a classroom where most of the teaching can be done in a discussion. For science or even mathematics, it seems to offer more distraction than an actual tool for students to raise questions.

Actually, I recall Joanne Nakonechny from Skylight at UBC mentioning the use of tweets in a classroom, but she wasn't really specific on the topic, I guess you know her, you could ask.

By David Kohler (not verified) on 15 Dec 2009 #permalink

"I'm curious to hear general opinions on whether this is good thing to try out"

Of course it is a good thing to try out -- as long as you are comfortable with giving up some control. It may not work for you, but you and your students might also fall in love with it...

If I had a lecture style class, I would give it a shot. I do think I would initially put some constraints on it. Punctuate the lecture with some specific points for students to share thoughts (either talking with a pair first or individually). They can tweet those thoughts so that they are public for you and the rest of the class...

This is very cool!

I actually think this would greatly enhance participation. I don't know how many times I've been in classes with people who have no engagement in the topic whatsoever. Most of the time, it's the traditional math and science courses that are being taught by a professor who lectures at the students. The students don't realize that they will learn more if they are actively engaged. Some take notes, a lot don't. Many nod off.

I started using my computer to take notes in classes (since I have learned LaTeX, it is possible to do so in math and science classes). When I am thinking about what's going on, sometimes I'll wonder where a prof got something. While they are talking, I google it and can find out something more. I think that having an active "discussion" would greatly enhance such classes, especially in the cattle call classes where everyone is afraid to ask questions. I think it would start turning people into active learners rather than ones who sit passively and hope to somehow absorb everything without any effort.

we have been using twitter and google wave for class notetaking in a computer supported cooperative work class. You are welcome to peruse the tweets at #cscwuvic if you like. I found wave to be a much more useful tool that twitter, though.

I just finished up a class which encouraged (actually it required) discussion via twitter along with hashtag usage. It was interesting the amount of refusal there was (when it was announced this would be required, people signed up with names like ForcedTweeter and some even dropped the class!) I was shocked by the backlash against twitter. Someone who was a writer in the class even tried to argue that nothing of substance could be stated in 140 characters. I think if you have a more mature student body it's a great idea and my peers were immature to reject it so forcefully.