Did 12 year olds make my iPhone?

Last night we went to see "The Agony and the Ecstasy of Steve Jobs" by Mike Daisey. Two hours vanished as we sat riveted and listened to interspersed stories of Apple and Shenzhen. Mike spoke of Apple and computers as a lover, familiar with the details, and knowledgeable in the special language of geeks and engineers. He was hysterically funny.

And we all understood.

After all, the night at the play was organized as a spring celebration by the Washington Technology Industry Association, a group intimately familiar with the ways of tech.

From the music preceeding the show, to Mike's stories of dabbling with the "heretical Linux" platform and even sleeping around with Windows, now and then in the late 90's, we laughed, having been there ourselves and lived those moments.

But once place we had never been was Shenzhen, China. We never knew that 50% of our electronics were made by Foxconn, a company of over 400,000 people who work in buildings surrounded by nets designed to catch suicidal workers. We never knew that teenagers worked 32 hour shifts and sometimes died afterwards. We never knew that our lovely Iphones and Ipads were assembled by hand, in 12 hour shifts, in silence, because people in China are cheaper than machines.

And we certainly didn't know the workers were children.

Mike described talking to people outside of factories, touring the plants, and hearing people's stories. And we found ourselves "infected with the mind virus" just as he described, knowing more than we wanted.

Perhaps he unfairly picked on Apple. It seems likely that Androids, Blackberrys, and other high tech items are built the same way. We expect computers that pride themselves on being cheap to be built in shoddy, unseemly surroundings.

But we hold Apple to a higher standard. Mike posed the question, as a long-time fan of Apple products and committed Apple user. He asked how Apple, a company so obsessed with detail, be unaware that their products are being assembled by children, in dystopian 1984 style factories.

We went home after the play and turned on our computers. And thought maybe there should be the computer equivalent of fair-trade coffee.

Maybe the Gates Foundation could detour a bit from malaria and push computer factories to "think different."

More like this

by Elizabeth Grossman The morning after President Obama's State of the Union speech that featured plans for reinvigorating U.S. manufacturing, Marketplace Morning Report asked former Obama Administration economic advisor Jared Bernstein why a company like Apple doesn't create more jobs in the U.S…
Mac Users Guide Flickr Photostream As a technophile, I do love my iPhone and iPod as portable portals to new media, the web and entertainment. But everything comes at a price. I was reminded of this, starkly, by a brilliant commentary by Mike Daisy, featured recently on NPR's This American Life…
Razib Khan has a good response to my post yesterday about biopunks, including this: I obviously support this movement and its intents (I've met a few of the people who are prominent in it). But we need to keep perspective here. This will probably be analogous to the free or open source software…
National Sleep Awareness Week might have been last week, but many of us are feeling the importance of shuteye this week, as we struggle to drag ourselves out of bed at what feels like an inappropriate hour. While Daylight Saving Time may get the blame for sleepiness this week, though, there are…


Read the actual *information* behind the story - Apple has clearly done more than any other manufacturer to both a) publicize what's really going on in the factories, and b) improve the lives of the workers.

Yes; there's certainly more to do.

No; crying "the sky is falling" is doing *nothing* to help.

By Marc Farnum Rendino (not verified) on 01 May 2011 #permalink

Do you have citations Marc?

I really want to get an Ipad2 and I would love to know that Apple is being a leader in supporting humane labor practices.

A Google search for Apple Foxconn China: http://goo.gl/gnyYA

The results seem mixed at first perusal.

By James Pomeroy (not verified) on 02 May 2011 #permalink