evolvingthoughts

Profile picture for user evolvingthoughts
John Wilkins

Posts by this author

March 15, 2009
As you may have noticed, I am something of a Victorian - as well as being from that wonderful state, I also write as if I were a nineteenth century writer. It comes of reading too many of them over too long a period. I have little trouble when the parentheses separate the beginnings from the ends…
March 14, 2009
A while back I excerpted some Whewell on classification by types. Here is John Stuart Mill disagreeing with him, and, I think, starting off the modern literature on natural kinds. Kinds are Classes between which there is an impassable barrier; and what we have to seek is, marks whereby we may…
March 11, 2009
In this age the mere example of non-conformity, the mere refusal to bend the knee to custom, is itself a service. Precisely because the tyranny of opinion is such as to make eccentricity a reproach, it is desirable, in order to break through that tyranny, that people should be eccentric.…
March 11, 2009
According to this cartoon, hat tip to Tangled Up in Blue Guy :
March 11, 2009
Taxonomy - the science of classifying organisms into putatively natural groups - is often treated as a kind of necessary bit of paperwork without much theoretical import by some biologists. Others think it is the single most important thing to do, usually justifying it in terms of conservation…
March 11, 2009
Leiter's poll has Wittgenstein beating Frege. I'm disappointed that Peirce didn't get a higher ranking, and astonished the Nietzsche did.
March 9, 2009
A talk Michael Ruse gave recently in Sydney for the celebrations of Darwin's 200th birthday is now available as a podcast from the ABC (Australian Broadcasting Corporation) here. Or here:
March 9, 2009
Apparently it's Pi day on March 14*, which means you get to eat a pie. But Americans do not understand what a pie is. That's not a pie... this is a pie: Real pies have meat, preferably with well-known common names like "beef", in them. And you eat them with tomato sauce, thusly: I once retraced…
March 9, 2009
Who knew that dialetheism was invented by kids?
March 7, 2009
Archetype is a blog on stuff I like, including taxonomy and entomology. It's by Roberto Keller, a graduate of AMNH and Cornell. Go check it out. Some nice stuff on homologies in insects.
March 6, 2009
There's been a highly publicised conference at the Vatican about evolution. There are good and sensible things being said there, and silly ones. The good and sensible things are that nobody questions that evolution occurs, and it is asserted that faith and science cannot conflict (which means,…
March 5, 2009
Heh.
March 4, 2009
An interesting article is up at the New Atlantis by Ari Schulman, arguing that we will never be able to replicate the mind on a digital computer. Here I want briefly to argue there are other reasons for this. Transhumanists are fond of claiming that one day we will be able to download a state…
March 4, 2009
Darwin's Dangerous Idea, according to Daniel Dennett in the book by that name, is natural selection. This is often referred to as "Darwin's theory". But Darwin did not always think evolutionary events or processes were due to natural selection. First off, let's say this again: Darwin did not think…
March 2, 2009
You all probably already knew about this comic series, but I needed Phil Plait to mention it. This is me. And... This is us collectively...
March 1, 2009
William Smellie wrote The Philosophy of Natural History in 1791, and it remained in print for over a century. It's a lovely and explicit expression of the Great Chain of Being view that all things grade insensibly from simple to perfect, and all classifications are arbitrary. This was effectively…
March 1, 2009
Actually, this one is better called "Darwin was a racist", but as the text concerned is from the same source as those claims, I thought it might be easier to evaluate a single claim and generalise from that. Our gospel for today is chapters V and VI of The Descent of Man, published in 1871. If you…
March 1, 2009
Brian Leiter has asked who that was in the train of the New York Times declaring that it was Wittgenstein.So far, Russell is leading. Russell? My goodness, he was important but hardly the best - most read more than best, I suspect. Moore was better than Russell. As to the other leading contenders,…
February 26, 2009
PD Magnus on the history of the philosophy of science in the last 50 years, in around 1400 words. A short primer on the Greenhouse Effect Mendeley, a bibliographic cloud project, has raised funding from Last.fm, Warner and Skype execs. Looks like next gen after Endnote...
February 26, 2009
Folks, I haven't forgotten you or the promised myth posts, but I've had to do some book stuff, along with Real Life stuff. So hang tight - I'm away this weekend (and - shock! - I'm not taking the laptop with me) but I promise something meaty on Sunday evening or so, OK? In the meantime: some X-Phi…
February 25, 2009
This is a kind of note to myself, an aide memoire to remind me of the fact that much of the modern narrative about classification in biology before Darwin is not correct. It's also interesting that Whewell defines systematics, but most interesting is the reinforcement of the prior note that Whewell…
February 22, 2009
I can't not do this, because I want to display to the world how nerdish and little of a life I have... Later note: The link above is crap. Instead I'm replacing it with the actual BBC Book list. Instructions: 1) Look at the list and put an 'x' after those you have read. 2) Add a '+' to the ones…
February 21, 2009
A 6th grade maths and science teacher emailed me about whether theories could become laws. Below the fold is his request and my reply. The short answer is that when laws grow up, they become theories, not the other way around. Cameron Peters wrote: Dr. Wilkins, I was hoping you might be able to…
February 21, 2009
A new blog that looks promising is here. In one of their first pieces they note that Cameroon is following the Congo's example and setting up preserves for gorillas (and other things).
February 20, 2009
This myth says a lot about the default views of western thinking, rather like the issue of teleology. One of the constant and incessant complaints made against Darwin by theists in particular, is that he introduced chance and purposelessness into our worldview. I don't believe in such entities as…
February 19, 2009
This myth has more to do with what people thought their own views contrasted to, than anything Darwin said, but like all myths, there's a hint of truth underlying it. The problem with this myth is the ambiguity of the term "gradual". It is a weasel word, which can mean one thing at one point and…
February 17, 2009
Once upon a time, I made mention, simply a mention, of a paper by one Matts Envall, which I said I would later comment on. I did so because a friend of mine, Malte Ebach, told me about him and the paper. I have yet to appropriately thank Malte. My gratitude involves a water balloon, I think. This…
February 16, 2009
I finally have internet - only took Primus three weeks to install and get working my internet and phone - and that was with an existing account and line! Tonight I went to the opening of a Thomas Henry Huxley exhibit at the Macleay Museum, and Michael Ruse gave an excellent talk on Tom and his…
February 16, 2009
I have always had a sneaking admiration for neo-Thomistic accounts of creation and evolution, because they tend to think of creation as the actualisation of the real world with no limitations on natural law within the created universe. Now read this nice piece by Michael Tkacz. You need not agree…