Cool Visual Illusions: Depth Inversion

depthinversion.bmpAs you all know, I love visual illusions, and this may be one of my favorites. This picture is pretty small (go here for a bigger version), but you should be able to figure out what's going on by watching it for a moment. Notice that as the face flips over, you briefly see the concave surface of the back or inside of the mask, but it quickly switches back to a convex, upside-down mask. That's not because the image changes, though. Instead, your brain decides that faces can't be hollow, so it changes it for you. This is called depth inversion, or the "hollow face illusion." Interestingly, depth inversion doesn't seem to occur for most objects (e.g., a "hollow potato")1. Thus it is often taken as evidence for the existence of a special system for processing faces.

Perhaps the most striking aspect of the illusion is how resistant it is to ordinary depth cues. As Richard Gregory wrote2:

This bias of seeing faces as convex is so strong it counters competing monocular depth cues, such as shading and shadows, and also very considerable unambiguous information from the two eyes signalling stereoscopically that the object is hollow... The effect is weaker when the mask is placed upside down, strongest for a typical face. If the mask is rotated [as in the above image -- Chris], or the observer moves, it appears to rotate in the opposite to normal direction, at twice the speed; because distances are reversed motion parallax becomes effectively reversed. (p. 1122)

The overriding of normal depth cues indicates that the effect is the result of top-down influences. In other words, our knowledge of faces is influencing our visual perception of them.

It's also interesting to note that that the illusion is reduced in schizophrenics3, when you're really really drunk (or when alcoholics are going through withdrawal)4, or when you're high on marijuana5. Apparently each of these states involves a disconnect between knowledge and sensory systems. Some researchers have argued that this disconnect may explain visual hallucinations in schizophrenia or during marijuana highs6.

1Hill, H. & Bruce, V. (1994). A comparison between the hollow-face and `hollow-potato' illusions. Perception, 23, 1335-1337.
2Gregory, R.L. (1997). Knowledge in perception and illusion. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 352(1358), 1121 - 1127.
3Schneider, U., Borsutzky, M., Seifert, J., Leweke, F.M., Huber, T.J., Rollnik, J.D., & Emrich, H.M. (2002). Schizophrenia Research, 53(1-2), 101-108.
4Schneider, U., Dietrich, D.E., Sternemann, U., Seeland, I., Gielsdorf, D., Huber, T.J., Becker, H., & Emrich, H.M. (1998). Reduced binocular depth inversion in patients with alcoholism. Alcohol & Alcoholism, 33(2), 168-172.
5Emrich, H.M., Weber, M.M., Wendl, A., Zihl, J., von Meyer, L., & Hanisch, W. (1991). Pharmacology, Biochemistry, and Behavior, 40(3), 689-690.


More like this

The hollow-face illusion is one of the most dramatic and robust illusions I've ever come across. It's been known for well over 200 years, but it never ceases to amaze me, as this video demonstrates: A three-dimensional hollow face mask held a few feet away will appear to be convex (turned "out"…
One of my favorite optical illusions is the rotating face, an instance of depth inversion. I like it so much that I sometimes use the above image as my avatar around the web. If you're not familiar with the illusion, what you're seeing is a 3D mask, one side of which is convex, while the other is…
I frequently hear people imply, if they don't state directly, that two working eyes are required for depth perception. This is surprising because with a moment's reflection, it's easy to see that there are depth cues that don't require both eyes. In fact, out of the many, many cues to depth that…
I was reminded of this illusion by the Seed Daily Zeitgeist yesterday. In order to get the full effect, I'll show you one set of photos here, and the rest of the post will be below the fold. The first are from Schwanginer et al. (2003)1: They look pretty normal, right? Now look at these: Gross,…

I'm not schizophrenic or under the influence of anything except a beer or two, but the gif doesn't ever do the reversal for me. I see it as concave through the entire half of the rotation when it's upside-down. Am I some sort of freak?

Also, is the effect stronger on the movie version isntead of the gif? Because I only looked at the gif.

There is definitely something wrong with your visual system! Kidding... you should probably try the larger version. If it still doesn't work, consult a neurologist.