Love's Kind Of Crazy With A Spooky Little Boy/Girl Like You

The lyrics to Dusty Springfield's 1970 song ”Spooky” are slightly odd. They have a woman describing her relationship with a fickle, unreliable, flirtatious man. ”Love's kind of crazy with a spooky little boy like you”. She constantly finds him winking with his “little eye” at other women. “I get confused and I don't know where I stand / But then you smile and hold my hand.” On the other hand, she won't give him a straight answer when he tries to ask her out. For the time definitely, and largely to a 2014 audience as well I believe, the gender roles in the lyrics are confusing. This is because what Dusty recorded was a gender-flipped version of the original lyrics.

The tune to “Spooky” was written by Mike Sharpe and Harry Middlebrooks Jr. and released as an instrumental in 1967. Later that year it received lyrics by James Cobb and Buddy Buie and was put out by the Floridian rock quartet the Classics IV. In January 1968 Dusty Springfield recorded her version. The original lyrics are about a spooky little girl behaving exactly like she might be expected to in mid-60s pop lyrics. Also they have a verse that was omitted from Dusty's version, clearly because it couldn't be gender-flipped convincingly at the time:

Just like a ghost, you've been a-hauntin' my dreams
So I'll propose... on Halloween

There's one final wrinkle to this story that makes it even better. Dusty Springfield, being gay, would probably have preferred to record the original lyrics. Love, after all, is kind of crazy with a spooky little girl like you.


More like this

A buddy of mine tagged me on Facebook to post a good song every day for a week. Here's what I came up with. 2000s. Robert Plant's (once of Led Zep) beautiful 2002 cover of ”Song To The Siren”. The original was first performed by Tim Buckley (Jeff's dad) in 1968. Pay attention to the lyrics by Larry…
Ever wondered why it's "red states"? Because it's the "red right". And as one of my favourite Australian lyricists has it, this is because of the red right hand: Take a little walk to the edge of town, go across the tracksWhere the viaduct looms, like a bird of doom as it shifts and cracksWhere…
I spent most of yesterday huddled under a pile of blankets on the couch-- being feverish and light-headed is great if you're in a Pink Floyd song, but not so much if you're trying to be a functioning adult. It seems to be the Thing That's Going Around this term, though, and while I'm feeling better…
GOAT: the new groovy weirdness from Gothenburg Here are some good albums that I've been listening to lately. Dowling Poole - Bleak Strategies (2014). For all who miss the later Beatles and the Super Furry Animals. GOAT - World Music (2012). Eclectic psychedelia with screamy female vocals and…

Hearing the Classic IV version ignited some Traces in my memories. Seems there were up-and-down relationships going on - One girlfriend was Spooky, then one was Stormy but finally one was Sunny.

By Lynn Dewees (not verified) on 15 Mar 2014 #permalink

If Dusty Springfield had been diagnosed with breast cancer today, she would have had much better chances to survive. No big breakthrough, but lots of small improvements.

By Birger Johansson (not verified) on 19 Mar 2014 #permalink

@Martin. In future when you're going to post something like this, give us a bit of warning that it's an earworm, can't you? I've got the chorus going round and round in my head. Grrr.