What kind of bird landed on Bernie's podium?

You all know this happened.

But there is some controversy over what kind of bird it is.

There is no doubt whatsoever that the bird was a finch. However, what kind? Most likely a house finch, because they are common, and the most likely to live in a big auditorium thingie and not be fearful of people.

A pic of the bird is above. Here is another:

Screen Shot 2016-03-26 at 5.35.55 PM

What do you think it is?

More like this

tags: leucistic House Finch, Carpodacus mexicanus, birds, mystery bird, bird ID quiz [Mystery bird] leucistic House Finch, Carpodacus mexicanus, photographed on Farm Island near Pierre, South Dakota. [I will identify this bird for you tomorrow] Image: Terry Sohl, 16 February 2009 [larger view].…
tags: Purple Finch, Carpodacus purpureus, birds, mystery bird, bird ID quiz [Mystery bird] Purple Finch, Carpodacus purpureus -- a hatching-year bird of unknown sex -- photographed in central New York. [I will identify this bird for you tomorrow] Image: Rick Wright [larger view]. NOTE: Rick…
tags: Pine Siskin, Carduelis pinus, birds, mystery bird, bird ID quiz [Mystery bird] Pine Siskin, Carduelis pinus, photographed in Arizona. [I will identify this bird for you tomorrow] Image: Richard Ditch, 2008 [larger view]. Date Time Original: 2008:04:16 08:46:29 Exposure Time: 1/319 F-…
The Key for the above graphic: Donald Trump's FEMA is not ready for this storm. The entire federal government is understaffed, and there are funding problems, and this applies to FEMA as well. So, if you are anywhere in the area to be affected by this storm (the weather channel calls it Stella, I…

It was The Holy Spirit.

By Desertphile (not verified) on 26 Mar 2016 #permalink

I can't wait to see what SNL does with this.

I'm not a bird person, but near as I can tell from "All the Birds of North American" looks most like a house finch.

Did someone say Birdie Sanders?

By Obstreperous A… (not verified) on 26 Mar 2016 #permalink

a green (white) house finch

By angela lloyd (not verified) on 26 Mar 2016 #permalink

That's a white house finch.

Don't tell Donald, but I hear that Bernie has twelve finches.

My first thought on seeing the flash of yellow was that it's a pine siskin. I have a lot of them in my yard each year and they are far "tamer" than sparrows.

By Douglas C Alder (not verified) on 26 Mar 2016 #permalink

Angela, what is a green house finch? A variant of a house finch or some other species?

I thought a "white house finch" was a color morph of a house finch. If so, this is not what of those because it is not white. But I don't know my western birds very well.

Before I took a closer look, my first impression was a vireo. That's the problem with going by color. The lighting, camera, and color context can be very deceptive.

Going by color alone in the two shots above, you might be tempted to say it was two different birds.

Aside from the overall form of the bird, a hard look at the patterns of light and dark on the folded wings and breast is revealing. To my untutored eye, it's a reasonably close match to the female house finch in my guide.

By Obstreperous A… (not verified) on 27 Mar 2016 #permalink

Evening Grosbeak

It's a female house finch.

"white house finch" above is a joke based on the office Bernie is running for, I'm sure.

Definitely not an evening grosbeak. Those are huge, bright yellow and black. This is either a pine siskin or a house finch in odd lighting.

It looks like a finch to me. Hard to tell from color, but it seems a bit greenish, which could be the female Goldfinch. The males are bright yellow, but the juveniles and females are more plain and can look chartreuse/ brown. They just showed up 2 weeks ago in Denver, so they're coming back from migration.

Female House Finch.

By Gilbert Wald (not verified) on 27 Mar 2016 #permalink

After consulting my bird books, I think the bird on the podium was a female White-winged Crossbill and therefore a finch for sure.

By Susan Sass (not verified) on 27 Mar 2016 #permalink

Female house finch. It's been confirmed (sigh).

It's a house finch, folks! Love Bernie.

It's a house finch, folks!

Holy crap, Pierre-Normand Houle blew my mind with his comment! Love Bernie, love Finch, love Bernie and the finch.

Finch ?? hmmm My research tells me its an Omen Pigeon

By BeSpoke Folly (not verified) on 28 Mar 2016 #permalink

BeSpoke Folly: "My research tells me its an Omen Pigeon"

"Come with me, Mahhhhrk!"

By Desertphile (not verified) on 28 Mar 2016 #permalink

In reply to by BeSpoke Folly (not verified)

Female or Juvenile House Finch. Hubby is mostly reddish in Spring.

By Tess Elliott (not verified) on 28 Mar 2016 #permalink

I'd also say it's a pine siskin. House Finches look more red. I have never seen a house finch looking this yellow.

Yeah, actually I think it is a female house finch after all. Beak is to big for pine siskin and females don't have much red on them.

When I first saw house finches about four or five years ago here in Calgary, I had a bit of a hard time identifying them. They have gone from being very rare here to quite common year-round residents. I often see them in with house sparrows, so it is necessary to look fairly closely to distinguish the females of the two species - they aren't hard to tell apart, but you do have to see them clearly, since they are very similar in size, shape and "average" color.

I'm quite fond of them. They sing big long strings of pleasant, musical random tweatelage (unlike the house sparrows).

It has a heavily-streaked breast, so it can't be a goldfinch or lesser goldfinch, probably a female house finch and it's just the lighting that makes it look yellowish.

By Kathy Apodaca (not verified) on 28 Mar 2016 #permalink

I used my Audubon app to find this bird. The only bird that resembles this one and can be found in that area, and is the same size and shape, is the California Towhee. The bird family is New World Sparrows.

By Kristin Braly (not verified) on 30 Mar 2016 #permalink

My first thought, like Douglas', was Pine Siskin, but seeing the stills says otherwise.

By Dan Andrews (not verified) on 01 Apr 2016 #permalink

I think it's a Black and Blue finch. My sister insists that it is white and gold though.

By Chris R. Smith (not verified) on 09 Apr 2016 #permalink

Pine siskin. It's got a tiny bit of yellow. A female house finch is more whitish and brown. Also, pine siskins are known to be very unafraid of people. One landed on my son's head once when we were on our porch!

By Janis Bunten (not verified) on 13 Apr 2016 #permalink

I live in the neighborhood of the auditorium in Portland and I think it's a female pine siskin. I've been watching them in my yard all year.

A bird landed on my head yesterday as my daughter and I were leaving the grocery store. Beat that, Bernie.

May I say what I believe in my soul... At a time in my life of extreme significance to me personally I had such a bird- but the male coloring- appear in a thunderous downpour at my window, yelling and beating his wings on the window. When I accepted what it was, it flew away. I know it was an emanation of God's love. I have held it as one of the most sacred experience of my life. It still means everything to me. The female goldfinch that landed for Bernie, I am certain in my heart of hearts was -an emanation of the Holy Spirit. And we have all seen this too. I feel we are all beyond fortunate. Bernie has awakened and developed me closer to living from my spiritual center or soul and ability to live in unconditional love moment by moment when I am mindful. Seeing that beautiful bird has given me great hope for humanity.

I just did a search to see about birds in spiritual traditions. I am a Buddhist but interested in Christianity and so looked into the Bible references and there are many to sparrows which I then followed to links that explain "sparrow" is meant to include any little bird alike it. It says many things but one I found said it is a symbol of God's concern for the meekest and weakest among us. I know Bernie shares that concern.

So no one has made mention of the difference between Bernie's bird and Trump's? (A Bald Eagle)
Bernie's bird attended his rally and said its piece.
Trump's bird attacked him.
Nature DOES have a conscience and an opinion, as evidence clearly demonstrates.


By spixleatedlifeform (not verified) on 06 May 2016 #permalink