Trustees vs. Faculty

The Dean Dad posts lots of very interesting things that I end up not having time to link to-- you should be reading his blog every day, if you're interested in how academia operates. This one is too good to not link, though-- a discussion of Boards of Trustees and how they operate. I particualrly enjoyed this bit:

Boards are usually relatively small, and often dominated by a few strong personalities. Board members are typically not, um, experts in the innards of higher education, having earned their stripes in other fields of endeavor. Board service is usually only one of the obligations a Board member has, and usually not the primary one. The information the Board receives is necessarily partial and filtered, and will often be read through lenses that faculty would consider utterly bizarre. (In William Chace's memoir One Hundred Semesters, he recalls a Board member applying true corporate logic - as opposed to mere cost-consciousness - to argue for eliminating the social sciences altogether at one university. His argument was that you don't compete in fields you can't dominate, and the university was far from dominant in the social sciences. Chace had to at least appear to take him seriously, and gently introduce him to the notion of 'general education.') One of the most critical jobs for a President and/or Provost and/or VP is to translate the norms of higher ed to language that Board members can both understand and respect. Faculty who routinely bash administration have little clue how much effort is spent on this, and what would happen if it weren't.

Read, as they say, the whole thing.

Tags

More like this

Dave Eaton, Mouth of Yecke, public advocate of poor education,
One of the highlights of teaching introductory mechanics is always the "karate board" lab, which I start off by punching through a wooden board. That gets the class's attention, and then we have them hang weights on boards and measure the deflection in response to a known force.
This just in from the NCSE: The future of science education in Texas is on the line. The Texas Board of Education, after two previous contentious public hearings on high school science standards (TEKS), meets March 25-27 for its final vote.
Wes Elsberry has caught a major falsehood in an article published by the American Enterprise Institute, written by one of their research ana

Professional management is about leadership not facts. Lower echelons interpret orders into actions and are held accountable for their failings. Management enters relationships to broker power (El Ultimo Presidente Boosh the Lesser, the Decider! Democracy, Haliburton; expendable assets.)

Universities exist wherein goo and dribbles of a liberal education are excised in favor of objective achievement. MIT, Caltech, RPI... are techno-slaves born and borne. Fraternities educate our socially interwoven leaders, sororities train their visible social adjuncts.

Every corporate stool has three legs: Labor, sacrifice, and the crushing burden of command. Compensation is commensurately awarded.

Uncle Al: "Universities exist wherein goo and dribbles of a liberal education are excised in favor of objective achievement. MIT, Caltech, RPI... are techno-slaves born and borne."

Are you suggesting that Caltech does not have world-class faculty in Humanities and Social Sciences?